In order to give you a better service Pepperl+Fuchs uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our

 use of cookiesI agree.
Serviceline Industrial Sensors
Sales phone: 0161 622 6308
Tech phone: 0161 622 6311
Fax: 0161 624 6537
Serviceline Explosion Protection
Sales phone: 0161 622 6309
Tech phone: 0161 622 6313
Fax: 0161 624 6537

Did You Find Out? Get the Answer to the Riddle


The witch recites a spell

The witch recites a spell beginning with the puzzling verses of Goethe's witch`s one-times-one.
The witch recites a spell beginning with the puzzling verses of Goethe's witch`s one-times-one.

Two old witches brew a magical rejuvenation potion in their kitchen. Before they drink the mysterious cocktail, one of the witches recites a spell. It begins with the puzzling verses of the witch`s one-times-one of Goethe's famous "Faust".

"This you must ken!
From one make ten,
And two let be,
Make even three,
Then rich you'll be.

With the witch's one-time-one, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe swirled the world of numbers properly. But who knows, maybe the famous poet was inspired by the equation below. This seems to prove that 2 = 1is that right?

                  a = b                       | • a            We multiply both sides by “a”

                 a² = a b                    | + a²           Now we add on both sides “a²”

         a² + a² = a b + a²               | - 2ab          Then we subtract ”2ab”

a² + a² - 2ab = a b + a² - 2ab                           … and calculate (simplify)

      2a² - 2ab = a² - ab                                   … and exclude

  2 • (a² - ab) = 1 • (a² - ab)          | : (a² - ab)   Finally, both sides are divided by “(a² - ab)”

                  2 = 1


The calculation begins with the equation a = b.

However, if a = b, then a² = ab and thus the expression (a ² - ab) is equal to zero. In the last step of the calculation it is therefore divided by zero, which is generally known to be prohibited in mathematics. Thus, the supposed proof that 2 = 1, is wrong and with the witch`s one-times-one Goethe cannot rely on mathematics but only to his poetic license.


Subscribe to our newsletter and receive regularly news and interesting information around the world of automation.


Read the current issue of e-news: